Tuesday, April 27, 2010

The Cuban Missile Crisis

1. Kennedy described Wednesday, Oct. 24 and Saturday, Oct. 27 as the darkest days of the crisis. Use the information on page 350 to explain why.
Wednesday, Oct. 24 was the beginning of the blockade: the first sign that the U.S. was truly getting involved in the crisis, the first point of action. After that, there was no turning back. Saturday, October 27 marked the first American casualty; Kennedy was forced to consider actually going to war.
2. Do you think that nuclear war was ever a possibility in this crisis?
I do not believe that nuclear war was truly a possibility in this crisis. Both countries knew that they had the power to wipe each other out completely; both were too afraid of retaliation to launch on the other. This crisis was more of a show of power - whoever could flex the bigger muscles would win.

3. Is Source 26 a Soviet or an American cartoon? Explain your answer by referring to the details in the cartoon.
This is an American cartoon. The biggest clue pointing to this is that JFK seems to be having less trouble than Khruschev - he is sweating less, implying that he has the upper hand. Also, more detail is shown in the drawing of Kennedy - the author clearly wanted to make him look good, whereas Khruschev is drawn much more simply.

4. Using Source 27 list any evidence you can find for and against each of the explanations.
Why did the Soviet Union place nuclear missiles on Cuba?
To bargain with the USA
-Neither country truly wanted war
-Bargaining could have avoided any violence
-Tensions were so high at this point that bargaining seemed unlikely to work
To test the USA
-The USSR was constantly trying to tell how powerful the US' weapons were
-This situation could have proven very, very dangerous for the Soviet Union
To trap the USA
-If the US struck first, the Soviet Union would look like the victim in the situation
-neither country wanted to provoke the other; no matter who struck first, there would still be terrible consequences
To get the upper hand in the arms race
-The Cold War was really just a power play
-It was more about impressions than actual fighting
-The USSR had a need to prove itself superior to the US
-Getting the upper hand would just cause the US to bump up their own arms supply
To defend Cuba
-The USSR woudl have been happy to have Communism spread so far across the globe
-The USSR had promised to support and protect any satellite nations
-The USSR was too busy dealing with the US to get involved in what could turn into a complicated civil war

5. Choose the explanation(s) that you think best fit what you have found out about the crisis. Explain your choice.
I believe that the USSR was trying to gain the upper hand in the arms race. The Soviet Union felt very threatened by the US missiles in Turkey; by placing missiles in Cuba, they threatened the US in the same way. The Cold War was all about getting the upper hand. The race to have more and better technology was constant. While the Soviet Union and the U.S. did not actually want war, both wanted to look better than the other; for this reason, it only seems logical that the USSR was motivated mainly by a need to gain an upper hand in the arms race.

No comments:

Post a Comment